Xtreme Modelling Contest 2006/07

2.Weltkrieg Kategorie:

Die Plätze 7-17

Wertung

Fotobewertung

Detlev Kaczmarek
43,5 Punkte

Juror	A-Note	B-Note	Gesamtnote
"Mig" Jimenez	3,8	4,2	8,0
J. de Luelmo	4,0	4,5	8,5
J. Javier Laínez	3,9	4,1	8,0
Z.Belan	4,9	4,9	9,8
T.Hartwig	3,9	5,3	9,2

Light: Good

General Focus: Regular. Many grain. The optic of the camera looks bad.

Detail Focus: The same

Framing: Bad. Gun barrels trimmed. Main subjects not clears. Many empty spaces.

Rate: 2/6

Erik Helm
41,5 Punkte

Juror	A-Note	B-Note	Gesamtnote
"Mig" Jimenez	3,3	4,0	7,3
J. de Luelmo	4,0	5,0	9,0
J. Javier Laínez	3,3	3,8	7,1
Z.Belan	4,8	4,8	9,6
T.Hartwig	3,6	4,9	8,5

Light: Good

General Focus: Good. The optic of the camera looks bad.

Detail Focus: Regular

Framing: Regular. Many empty spaces.

Rate: 3,5/6

Martin Rauscher
41,2 Punkte

Juror	A-Note	B-Note	Gesamtnote
"Mig" Jimenez	3,9	3,5	7,4
J. de Luelmo	4,5	4,0	8,5
J. Javier Laínez	3,3	4,8	8,1
Z.Belan	4,1	4,1	8,2
T.Hartwig	4,3	4,7	9,0

Light: Good, maybe a few light in some photos

General Focus: Good

Detail Focus: Good

Framing: Good. The background could be improved very much.

Rate: 4,5/6

Helge Hiddensen
41,1 Punkte

Juror	A-Note	B-Note	Gesamtnote
"Mig" Jimenez	4,5	3,4	7,9
J. de Luelmo	4,0	3,5	7,5
J. Javier Laínez	4,2	2,7	6,9
Z.Belan	4,9	4,9	9,8
T.Hartwig	4,2	4,8	9,0

Light: Good

General Focus: Good

Detail Focus: Regular

Framing: Good

Rate: 5/6

Erik Helm
40,0 Punkte

Juror	A-Note	B-Note	Gesamtnote
"Mig" Jimenez	3,5	3,8	7,3
J. de Luelmo	4,0	3,5	7,5
J. Javier Laínez	3,0	3,8	6,8
Z.Belan	4,7	4,7	9,4
T.Hartwig	4,3	4,7	9,0

Light: Good

General Focus: Good. The optic of the camera looks bad.

Detail Focus: Regular

Framing: Regular. Many empty spaces.

Rate: 3,5/6

Nico Frenzel
38,4 Punkte

Juror	A-Note	B-Note	Gesamtnote
"Mig" Jimenez	3,0	2,9	5,9
J. de Luelmo	3,0	3,5	6,5
J. Javier Laínez	4,2	3,3	7,5
Z.Belan	4,4	4,4	8,8
T.Hartwig	4,9	4,8	9,7

Light: Good. Strong upper light.

General Focus: Regular. The optic of the camera looks bad.

Detail Focus: Regular

Framing: Regular. Empty spaces and trimmed parts.

Rate: 3/6

Walter Pieczyk
38,3 Punkte

Juror	A-Note	B-Note	Gesamtnote
"Mig" Jimenez	4,0	4,0	8,0
J. de Luelmo	4,0	4,0	8,0
J. Javier Laínez	3,6	2,9	6,5
Z.Belan	3,7	3,7	7,4
T.Hartwig	3,9	4,5	8,4

Light: Good.

General Focus: Good

Detail Focus: Regular

Framing: Good

Rate: 5/6

Bernd Kriesmair
37,5 Punkte

Juror	A-Note	B-Note	Gesamtnote
"Mig" Jimenez	3,5	4,0	7,5
J. de Luelmo	4,0	3,5	7,5
J. Javier Laínez	3,6	3,8	7,4
Z.Belan	3,8	3,8	7,6
T.Hartwig	3,6	3,9	7,5

Light: Very good

General Focus: Very good

Detail Focus: Good, but with few field depth.

Framing: Good

Rate: 5/6

Claudio Rieder
37,4 Punkte

Juror	A-Note	B-Note	Gesamtnote
"Mig" Jimenez	3,0	3,5	6,5
J. de Luelmo	4,0	4,0	8,0
J. Javier Laínez	3,6	3,9	7,5
Z.Belan	3,9	3,9	7,8
T.Hartwig	3,4	4,2	7,6

Light: Very good

General Focus: Good

Detail Focus: Regular.

Framing: Regular

Rate: 4/6

Kai Menzel
35,9 Punkte

Juror	A-Note	B-Note	Gesamtnote
"Mig" Jimenez	2,8	2,4	5,2
J. de Luelmo	3,5	3,0	6,5
J. Javier Laínez	3,6	3,0	6,6
Z.Belan	3,9	3,9	7.8
T.Hartwig	5,2	4,6	9,8

Light: Good

General Focus: Good

Detail Focus: Good

Framing: Regular. Many empty spaces.

Rate: 4,5/6

Torsten Schulz
35,2 Punkte

Juror	A-Note	B-Note	Gesamtnote
"Mig" Jimenez	3,5	3,9	7,4
J. de Luelmo	3,5	4,0	7,5
J. Javier Laínez	3,9	3,0	6,9
Z.Belan	3,1	3,1	6,2
T.Hartwig	3,2	4,0	7,2

Light: Good

General Focus: Good

Detail Focus: Regular

Framing: Regular. Parts trimmed. Main subject slightly out of place.

Rate: 3/6

Hier geht zurück zu den Plätzen 1 bis 6